Beyond Structured Settlements

Mixed ELNY Reactions

In an article titled "Loss for Policyholders", written by James Campbell and published April 17, 2012 in the Wall Street Journal (WSJ), Executive Life of New York (ELNY) stakeholders expressed contrasting reactions to Judge John M. Galasso's decisions to:

• Approve the ELNY Restructuring Agreement proposed by the Superintendent of the New York State Department of Financial Services (Superintendent); and
• Grant judicial immunity to the Superintendent, as ELNY's Receiver, and the New York Liquidation Bureau (NYLB) "for any action or omission by any one or more of them when acting in good faith, in accordance with this Order, or in the performance of their duties pursuant to Insurance Law Article 74 ..."

Shortfall Payee

Eric Rabinowitz, a 43-year-old Manhattan man, who received an ELNY-funded structured settlement in 1983 after being blinded in his right eye during a cataract operation, told the WSJ: "They hung us out to dry and they knew for years that this thing didn't get properly protected and yet they gave us a few weeks to lawyer-up in holiday season."

Shortfall Payee Attorney

Connecticut attorney Edward Stone represents 12 payees whose combined ELNY benefits, according to the WSJ article, will be cut by $20 million under the approved plan. The article quotes Stone as saying: "Their benefits are being cut by more than 50%. One of my clients is being cut by 58%. This will mean major changes, and it may impact their ability to get medical care. One of my clients will have to file bankruptcy because the guarantees they were promised are not really guarantees at all."

According to Schedule 1.15 of the ELNY Restructuring Agreement, 1459 structured settlement payees will experience shortfalls ("uncovered amounts") as a result of ELNY's liquidation and restructuring even after state guaranty association contributions and voluntary enhancements by life insurance companies.

Stone also informed the WSJ: "the judge rejected his bid to call a number of witnesses to probe the [NYLB's] management of the company, including a former ELNY president, an actuary, a forensic accountant and a fraud expert."

Spokesman for Superintendent

David Neustadt, a spokesman for the Superintendent, disagreed with Stone's suggestion that the Superintendent and the NYLB might be guilty of mismanaging ELNY during the 20 plus years they supervised ELNY's Rehabilitation. "This is an absurd and baseless suggestion from a small-group of self-interested plaintiff's lawyers seeking to enrich themselves," Neustadt said.

Structured Settlement Industry Spokesman

Eric Vaughn, Executive Director of the National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA) "defended the structured-settlement industry, amid the failure of the ELNY rehabilitation" according to the WSJ article. Vaughn stated: "The Executive Life insolvency remains the only instance where any insurer of structured-settlement annuity has not made all payments in full and on time." In addition, according to Vaughn, "several hundred of the structured-settlement recipients might be able 'to recover shortfalls from the original insurers and other parties that have continuing responsibility under settlement agreements.'"

For S2KM's complete and continuing reporting about the ELNY liquidation, see the structured settlement wiki - and more specifically related to this blog post:

• The ELNY Due Process Issue - have anticipated shortfall victims received due process?
• The ELNY Immunity Issue - including and featuring Peter Bickford's analysis.
• ELNY Objections and Replies - summarizing arguments in the Superintendent's Reply Memorandum.

NSSTA 2011 Education Meeting

The National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA) hosted one of its best-ever educational programs November 2-4, 2011 in Austin, Texas. The conference primarily showcased NSSTA members and NSSTA member executives and encompassed a variety of important industry topics.

Speakers and topics:

NSSTA President Dan Finn - Finn summarized NSSTA's current projects, emphasized NSSTA's improved structured settlement marketing and announced the 2012 NSSTA Annual Meeting which will take place in Washington, D.C. and feature Congressmen Dave Camp and Paul Ryan as Keynote Speakers.

NSSTA Executive Director Eric Vaughn - In addition to reviewing the 112th Congress and Super Committee, Vaughn discussed the following NSSTA challenges and priorities:

• Protect IRC sections 104(a)(2) and 130.
• Defend structured settlements.
• Promote the expanded use of structured settlements.
• Expand the markets for structured settlements.
• Enhance the CSSC designation.
• Provide state court judicial education about structured settlements.

AIG Chief Economist Ardanvan Mobasheri - Mobasheri's economic overview highlighted China's emerging leadership, outlined a "very healthy non-financial business world" and predicted low interest rates for the foreseeable future.

American General Life President Mary Jane Fortin - Describing AIG as "a strong, stable and resilient company dedicated to keeping our promises", Fortin dispelled several "myths" about AIG, summarized AIG's recovery and expressed optimism about the future of life insurance industry and structured settlements.

John McCulloch and Michael Miller - Reprising NSSTA "Tax Posse", McCulloch and Miller introduced the new IRS audit guide for lawsuits, awards and settlements and reviewed recent tax cases addressing employment, factoring and Qualified Settlement Fund issues.

Peter Vodola, Stephen Harris and Amy Ravitz - The co-chairpersons of NSSTA's Legal Committee participated in two separate panels moderated by James Ebel and Michael Kelly and discussed non-tax cases and issues including state structured settlement protection statutes, issues arising from transfer petitions and minors statutes and settlements.

Len Blonder and NSSTA General Counsel Craig Ulman - Blonder and Ulman reported the status of the Executive Life of New York (ELNY) liquidation, discussed the consequences for structured settlements and reviewed hypothetical case examples from the proposed ELNY Restructuring Agreement.

Karen Meyers, LeAnne Sprague, Doug Brand and Kathy Moghadas - In addition to discussing changes to the CSSC designation that will require annual CE credits, NSSTA sponsored a special four hour annuity education session designed to meet the requirements of the new state annuity transaction suitability laws.

CNA Commercial Liability Claims Vice President James Martin - Championing structured settlements as an "important competitive advantage" for liability insurers, Martin also emphasized the importance of linking structured settlements and structured settlement sales to claim department goals and metrics.

Ringler Radio Broadcaster Larry Cohen - When announced co-interviwer Mark Wahlstrom proved a "no show", Cohen glibly volleyed Eric Vaughn toughest questions. Three memorable Cohen quotes: "a lot of a little is a lot"; "vision without execution is hallucination"; and (applying his grandfather's wisdom to Executive Life's annuity rates ) "there is something wrong with this tuna fish."

Liberty Life Chief Underwriter Kevin Smith - Speaking about "Life Company Operating Metrics", Smith pointed out the dearth of structured settlement metrics and announced a collaborative project among multiple NSSTA life company members to develop a preliminary set of structured settlement operating metrics.

Attorney William C Chriss - Author of the new book "The Noble Lawyer", Chriss discussed legal and structured settlement ethics. Among his observations while discussing NSSTA's Code of Ethics:

• "We cultivate beliefs that justify our behaviors, not the other way around.
• "Unconscious bias, as opposed to intentional venality, cannot be deterred by criminal laws or post hoc sanctions.
• "The more people involved, the easier it is to defuse moral responsibility."

Congratulations to NSSTA's speakers and leaders (especially Education Chairpersons Toni Warbington and Don Engels as well as Finn, Vaughn and Associate Director Peter Arnold) for substantially upgrading NSSTA's educational program.

For S2KM reports about prior conferences of NSSTA and other structured settlement and settlement planning professional associations, see the structured settlement wiki.

SSP and NSSTA 2011 Annual Meetings - 2

This blog post continues S2KM's discussion of the 2011 annual conferences of the Society of Settlement Planners (SSP) and the National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA) with a strategic perspective. A prior S2KM blog post identified speakers and topics featured by SSP and NSSTA. Subsequent S2KM blog posts will summarize and provide commentary about selected speaker presentations.

SSP's conference, open to members and non-members, addressed two general topics: "Special Needs Settlement Planning" and "Practice Improvement: Marketing and New Products". NSSTA's conference, for members only, celebrated NSSTA's 25th anniversary. It also included a NSSTA business meeting with reports from immediate Past-President Michael Kelly, new President Dan Finn, Executive Director Eric Vaughn, Assistant Executive Director Peter Arnold and the Chairpersons of NSSTA's several committees.

One of the highlights of NSSTA's 2011 conference was the honoring of NSSTA's past presidents. David Ringler, NSSTA's first president, spoke briefly at the conference and re-stated his original vision for NSSTA:

"Although we do need to constantly be on the watch for legislative change, I still believe having a place where everyone and anyone can sit down with each other and discuss the issues and viewpoints regardless of beliefs is the most important reason for NSSTA. I have called it a common “talk table”, although I agree that is not exactly a very elegant term. If we can continue this tradition, there is no problem we cannot overcome."

Many industry participants, including some NSSTA members, question whether NSSTA has lost sight of this original purpose and tradition. Does NSSTA continue to represent "a place where everyone and anyone can sit down with each other and discuss [structured settlement] issues and viewpoints regardless of beliefs"? The answer, unfortunately, is "no".

For the past several years, NSSTA's leadership has superimposed a strict political litmus test for membership as well as for topics and speakers at its educational conferences. As one result, structured settlement industry participants with alternative issues, viewpoints, beliefs and educational interests have founded two other national structured settlement associations: the National Association of Settlement Purchasers (NASP) in 1996 and SSP in 2000.

Fortunately for NSSTA members and the structured settlement industry, based upon its 2011 conference, NSSTA appears to be expanding the scope of its educational programs to address important but controversial industry topics such as IRC 468B Qualified Settlement Funds, IRC 5891 and state structured settlement protection statutes. The educational programs offered by both NSSTA and SSP also increasingly discuss three fundamental transitions reshaping the structured settlement industry:

• From structured settlements to settlement planning;
• From a singular, illiquid, and non-assignable product to multiple products with greater flexibility to address changing needs and circumstances of injury victims;
• From traditional (pre-Internet) to web-based business models, processes and skill sets.

With the structured settlement industry facing these and other challenges, including aging leadership, declining structured settlement annuity sales, anticipated legislative changes plus an increasingly complex legal and regulatory business environment, where is the strategic vision and what are the strategic priorities for NSSTA and SSP?

NSSTA President Dan Finn and Executive Director Eric Vaughn identified the following:

• NSSTA challenges:
  • Promote the expanded use of structured settlements
  • Expand the structured settlement market
  • Protect structured settlement annuitants
  • Defend IRC sections 104(a) and 130
  • Enhance the Certified Structured Settlement Consultant (CSSC) program
  • Unify the structured settlement industry
• NSSTA objectives
  • Expand IRC section 104 (a)(2) to include wrongful imprisonment and sexual abuse cases
  • Expand government use of structured settlements
  • Promote structuring of MSAs in liability cases
  • Promote the structuring of Social Security disability payments
  • Promote the professionalism of structured settlements

SSP President Jack Meligan prioritized three objectives:

• Improve SSP's marketing to plaintiff attorneys
• Create an SSP lobbying presence
• Enhance the Registered Settlement Planner (RSP) certification program

Two of NSSTA's featured speakers, Jim Morris, President, Chairman and CEO of Pacific Life Insurance Company, and William T. Robinson lll, President-Elect of the American Bar Association (ABA), added important and positive assessments for structured settlements.

Morris accentuated the current financial strength of U.S. life insurance companies and explained why structured settlement annuities represent an excellent strategic product for life companies. As corollaries to Morris' presentation:

• NSSTA announced that two highly rated annuity providers, Mutual of Omaha and Berkshire Hathaway, have re-entered the structured settlement market; and
• Thomas Ronce and Craig Ulman clarified the life and health guaranty association system and how that system applies to structured settlements.

Robinson praised structured settlements as "professional and dignified solutions" for injury victims based upon his first-hand experience as a litigation attorney. Structured settlements represent "state of the art" tools for all attorneys to consider when negotiating and resolving personal injury cases according to Robinson. In his capacity as President-Elect of the ABA: Robinson also:

• Spotlighted the current funding crisis facing state courts; and
• Suggested the ABA and NSSTA should identify shared interests and lobbying opportunities.

For S2KM's reporting and commentary about past SSP and NSSTA conferences, see S2KM's structured settlement wiki.

SSP and NSSTA 2011 Annual Meetings - 1

This blog post begins S2KM's reporting and outlines results from the 2011 annual meetings of the Society of Settlement Planners (SSP - May 15-17) and the National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA - May 18-20).

Elections

• NSSTA
  • President - Dan Finn
  • New Directors - Tom Donahue; Christine Logan; Kevin Silo; Mike Wostoupal
• SSP
  • President - Jack Meligan
  • New Directors - Tony Alfieri; Tim Denehy; Charles Schell; Michelle Whitmore.

Honors - NSSTA

• President's Award - Betty Gregware
• Leadership Award - Toni Warbington
• CSSC Designation Certificates
• NSSTA Past Presidents - honoring NSSTA's 25th Anniversary

Educational Programs - speakers by topic with recommended related resources from "Structured Settlements and Periodic Payment Judgments" (S2P2J), S2KM wikis and prior S2KM blog posts.

Legislative Update

• NSSTA - Eric Vaughn: Washington Update
  
• SSP - Roy Franco: HR 1063
  

Government Benefits

• NSSTA
  • MSA Panel -Toni Warbington; Doug Brand; David Korch; David Hayes
  • Special Needs Trusts - Jay Sangerman
• SSP
  • Liability MSAs - Jason Lazarus; Roy Franco; Mark Pololizio; Doug Shaw
  • Liens Panel - Roy Franco; Tevra Johnson
• Recommended resources
  • S2P2J Chapter 15 - "Government Benefits and Structured Settlements"
  • S2 wiki - "Government Benefits"

Taxation

• NSSTA: 468B QSF Funds - Martin Jacobson
• SSP
  • 468B QSF Funds - Robert Wood
  • Taxation of Damages - Robert Wood
  • Medical Expense and Estate Tax Issues - Jeremy Babener
• Recommended resources
  • S2P2J Chapter 2 - "Taxation of Damages"
  • S2P2J Section 3.08B - "Section 468B Settlement Funds"
  • S2 public policy wiki pages featuring: Robert Wood and Jeremy Babener

Stakeholder Perspectives

• NSSTA
  • Attorneys - William Robinson lll, President-Elect of the American Bar Association
  • Legal Committee Update (including secondary market) - Peter Vodola; Amy Ravitz; Kathy Scanlon
  • Financial Planners - Laura Tarbox
  • Judges - Peter Vodola, Edward Burke, Stephen Denton
  • Unions - Michael Rott
• SSP
  • Special Needs Attorneys - Kevin Urbatsch; Michele Fuller
  • Plaintiff Attorneys - Jay Fisher
• Recommended resources
  • S2P2J Chapter 4 - "Defense Counsel"
  • S2P2J Chapter 5 - "Plaintiff Counsel"
  • S2P2J Chapter 6 - "Case Preparation"
  • S2P2J Section 16.05 - "Judicial Review of Transfer Applications"
  • S2 wiki - "Secondary Market"
  • S2KM blog - "Ceron v. Henderson"

Marketing

• NSSTA: Business Communications - LuAnn Reeb
• SSP
  • Marketing to Personal Injury Attorneys - Joe Didier
  • Electronic Media and Social Networking - Mark Wahlstrom
• Recommended resources
  • S2 wiki - "S2 and KM"
  • Web 2.0 for Lawyers wiki

Practice Improvement and New Products

• NSSTA: CSSC Continuing Education Online - Karen Meyers; Kathy Moghadas
• SSP
  • Dissecting a Settlement Plan - Jack Meligan; Joseph Tombs
  • Non-qualified Assignments - Brian Michael
  • Indexed Annuities - Rick Miller
  • Re-cycling Structured Settlement Payment Rights - Anthony Prieto; Tim Denehy
• Recommended resources
  • S2P2J Section 3.06A - "Non-Qualified Assignments"
  • S2 wiki - "Re-thinking Structured Settlements"
  • S2 wiki - "Settlement Consulting"
  • S2 wiki - "Business Standards and Practices"
  • S2 wiki - "Spencer v. Hartford"
  • S2KM blog - "Online S2P2J" 

Strength of Life Companies

• NSSTA
  • Strength of Life Insurance Companies - Jim Morris, Chairman, President and CEO of Pacific Life Insurance Company
  • State Guarantee Associations - Tom Ronce; Craig Ulman
  • ELNY Update - Len Blonder; Randy Dyer; Dan Finn; Craig Ulman

• Recommended resources
  • S2P2J Section 3.05[9] - "Life Insurance Guaranty Associations"
  • S2P2J Section 3.05[10] - "Executive Life Insolvency"
  • S2KM blog - "Executive Life of New York"

For S2KM reporting and analysis of prior SSP and NSSTA meetings, see S2KM's structured settlement wiki.

Structured Settlements in 2010 - 2

Beginning in 2004, S2KM has utilized this blog ("Beyond Structured Settlements") and related web 2.0 publications to report and analyze strategic developments impacting the structured settlement and special needs settlement planning (aka settlement consulting) industries.

Featuring industry leaders, commentators and professional association conferences, S2KM has attempted to highlight how legal and technology changes are redefining the traditional (pre-2001) structured settlement market including structured settlement public policy as well as structured settlement business standards, business practices and business models.

From S2KM's perspective, the following categories, people and developments defined the structured settlement and special needs settlement planning industries in 2010:

Professional associations

• S2KM attended seven professional educational conferences during 2010 which addressed structured settlement and/or special needs settlement planning issues:
  • National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA) - 2
  • Society of Settlement Planners (SSP)
  • National Association of Settlement Purchasers (NASP)
  • National Alliance of Medicare Set-Aside Professionals (NAMSAP)
  • National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys (NAELA)
  • Academy of Special Needs Planners (ASNP)
• As a general observation, all of these conferences were valuable and complementary. For S2KM's 2010 (plus historical) conference reports, see S2KM's structured settlement wiki.
• SSP, NASP and NAMSAP deserve special recognition for their 2010 strategic educational discussions featuring industry leaders, commentators and critics who offered alternative perspectives for improving and growing the structured settlement and special needs settlement planning markets.
• By comparison, NSSTA remains reluctant to openly discuss strategic industry issues or to include alternative perspectives in their educational programs. More positively, NSSTA representatives and members increasingly attend and speak at non-NSSTA structured settlement and special needs settlement planning conferences.
• NAELA's educational conferences are noteworthy because they regularly feature sections or entire programs titled "unprograms". NAELA's unprograms are moderated group discussions about specific topics. NAELA's 2010 Special Needs Summit included six separate one hour unprograms with a concluding unprogram wrap-up session. One example of a 2010 NAELA unprogram was titled "Collaboration Opportunities for Special Needs Attorneys and Financial Planners".

Industry leaders

• NSSTA promoted Eric Vaughn, who previously served as NSSTA's lobbyist, to replace Joseph Ricci as NSSTA's new Executive Director effective July 1, 2010. Peter Arnold, previously NSSTA's Marketing Director, was similarly promoted to serve as NSSTA's Associate Executive Director. NSSTA's Board of Directors elected Michael Kelly as its 2010 President and Dan Finn as its President-elect. NSSTA honored Congressman Peter Stark during its Annual Meeting as its 2010 Legislator of the Year. NSSTA also gave special recognition to Karen Meyers and Joseph Bornstein for their contributions to NSSTA's CSSC and NSSTAPAC programs respectively..
• SSP elected Jason Lazarus as its President for 2010-11 and Charles Schell as Vice President. SSP honored Richard Risk with the designation of "life member" for his contributions to SSP and the settlement planning industry. Joseph Tombs continues as Director of SSP's RSP certification program.
• NASP named Matthew Bracy as its new President succeeding Robin Shapiro. Earl Nesbitt continues as NASP's Executive Director.
• NAMSAP elected Michael Westcott as its President.
• NAELA honored Dick Traum as the first recipient of NAELA's Special Needs Leadership Award. Traum is the founder and CEO of Achilles International, a non-profit organization providing community support for athletes with disabilities with members in more than 70 countries.
• Amy Palmiero-Winters, ultra-marathoner and lower-leg amputee, was named during 2010 as the winner of the 2009 James E. Sullivan Award given annually to the top amateur athlete in the United States.

Industry commentators

• For the past several years, Robert Wood has been the preeminent tax commentator and author for the structured settlement and settlement planning industries. Wood's publications appear on the Wood & Porter website.
• During 2010, Jeremy Babener emerged as an important new structured settlement tax commentator and author specializing in public policy and proposing an expanded structured settlement tax subsidy. In addition to authoring several structured settlement articles for tax and legal journals, Babener participated as a featured speaker at both the SSP and NASP 2010 Annual Meetings and authored two blog posts for S2KM during 2010. Babener discussed his structured settlement writing (accessible on S2KM's structured settlement public policy wiki and Babener's Tax Structuring website) in this 2010 S2KM interview.
• Additional authors who wrote and published 2010 legal articles about structured settlement and special needs settlement planning issues included: Daniel Hindert, Matt Garretson, Sylvius von Saucken, Peter Wayne, Mark Popolizio, Gregg Polsky and Brant Hellwig.
• Both the Legal Broadcast Network and Ringler Radio continued to produce and distribute podcasts featuring structured settlement commentators during 2010.
• An increasing number of structured settlement and special needs settlement planning professionals published blogs during 2010 joining industry blogging pioneers such as John Darer, Mark Wahlstrom, Matthew Bracy and Jack Meligan.
• Incisive Media published two new updates (Release 47 and Release 48) for "Structured Settlements and Periodic Payment Judgments" during 2010.

Legislation

• Both the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (Health Care Reform) and the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank) redesign the legal environment in which the structured settlement and personal injury settlement planning markets operate.
• Among the anticipated strategic consequences of health care reform:
  • An estimated 16 million more Medicaid participants - and therefore:
  • More special needs trusts;
  • More special needs attorneys;
  • More structured settlement annuities payable to trustees.
• Dodd-Frank re-writes federal banking law and creates a new Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection. A key question, as yet unanswered, is whether the sale and/or purchase of structured settlement annuities constitutes a "financial product or service" under Dodd-Frank requiring regulatory supervision by the Bureau.

Regulations

• The United States Department of Treasury held a public hearing on February 23, 2010 focused on proposed new regulations for Internal Revenue Code section 104(a)(2). The proposed regulations, if enacted, would:
  • Eliminate the requirement that damages be based on “tort or tort type rights” in order to qualify for the section 104(a)(2) tax exclusion, and
  • Incorporate 1996 legislation requiring that personal injuries and sickness damages be “physical” in order to qualify for the section 104(a)(2) tax exclusion.
  • A subsequent S2KM interview featured John McCullough and Richard Risk, two of the structured settlement industry members who spoke at the hearing.
• The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) continued to issue administrative guidance during 2010 for enforcement of the Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) Act of 1980 and the Medicare, Medicaid and SCHIP Extension Act of 2007 (MMSEA) reporting requirements for insurers. Featured discussions during the NAMSAP 2010 Annual meeting highlighted:
  • The increasing importance and complexity of the MSP statute for all personal injury stakeholders;
  • The need for these personal injury stakeholders (and their professional associations) to cooperate politically and educationally;
  • The challenges of integrating structured settlements, including rated ages, with Medicare set-aside arrangements (MSAs) in the context of health care reform, CMS MSA regulations and related judicial rulings;
  • The evolving business models, claim management strategies and professional skill sets which are now emerging to address these challenges.

Case law

• The Spencer v. Hartford class action lawsuit which settled in 2010 represents one of the most important legal developments in the history of the structured settlement industry.
• Hartford's gross settlement payment of $72.5 million represents 4.5% of total premium dollars Hartford used to purchase structured settlement annuities for class members from January 1, 1997 to June 7, 2010.
• Among the plaintiffs allegations:
  • Hartford and its attorneys, brokers and agents violated the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) and committed common law fraud in structuring its settlements.
  • Hartford's structured settlements were priced so Hartford retained 15% of the value of the structured settlements.
  • Hartford and its attorneys, brokers and agents misrepresented structured settlements including explicit or implicit reference to:
    • The "cost" of the annuity or structured settlement or portion of the settlement being structured; and/or
    • The "value" of the annuity or structured settlement or portion of the settlement being structured.
• Hartford, which stopped writing new structured settlement business in 2009, denied the allegations.

Technology

• Despite the accelerating technology advances revolutionizing society generally, the structured settlement and special needs settlement planning industries have been slow to study and incorporate these advances into their educational programs and business models.
• The best industry-sponsored technology education programs during 2010 were offered by Mark Miller during a NAELA webinar and Harry Margolis at the ASNP 2010 Annual Meeting. Both presentations provided introductory overviews of web 2.0 and including recommendations for integrating specific social networking tools into special needs legal practices.
• NSSTA initiated a NSSTA blog during 2010 and offered an educational program about Internet marketing during its 2010 Fall Education program.

Public policy

• Both SSP and NASP featured specific discussions and presentations about structured settlement public policy during their 2010 Annual Meetings. The discussions included industry commentators representing diverse viewpoints and priorities.
• Jeremy Babener followed his 2009 paper debunking industry myths concerning "structured settlement dissipation studies" with several 2010 articles and papers addressing structured settlement public policy issues. Babener's public policy writing is featured on S2KM's structured settlement public policy wiki.
• Release 47 of "Structured Settlements and Periodic Payment Judgments" re-examined several structured settlement public policy issues related to single claimant 468B funds, structured settlement factoring transactions, dissipation by personal injury victims, the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005, special needs trusts and Medicare set-aside arrangements.
• In a 2010 Boston College Law Review article, professors Gregg Polsky and Brant Hellwig challenged the application of any structured settlement tax benefit for deferring attorney fees or payments to non-physically injured tort plaintiffs under general common law tax principles.

Business standards and practices

• The Spencer v. Hartford case raises many issues about structured settlement business standards and practices which require greater education and analysis if the primary market expects to improve and grow. For example;
  • Is the primary structured settlement market capable of self-regulation?
  • Why shouldn't key elements of the state structured settlement protection statutes (judicial approval; best interest test; compensation disclosure) be applied to primary market transactions?
  • As an additional requirement, or as an alternative, why haven't plaintiff attorneys and plaintiff consultants insisted upon a claimant's written informed consent before entering into a structured settlement?
  • Why haven't the SSP's Standards of Professional Conduct received more public discussion and analysis within the structured settlement industry?
• "Cash now" advertising represents one of the most highly criticized secondary market business practices. Although this practice continues to exist, NASP took an important educational step during its 2010 Annual Meeting by highlighting this issue and inviting secondary market critics to participate in the discussion.

Business models

• While other segments of, and products within, the special needs settlement planning market have expanded and improved in recent years, the structured settlement primary market in general has stagnated and retrenched.
• During 2010, however, representatives of the primary structured settlement market increasingly recognized their interdependency, and interacted, with other settlement planning professionals and professional associations such as special needs attorneys, life care planners, Medicare set-aside professionals and secondary structured settlement market participants.
• Future industry improvement and growth will require even greater appreciation and identification of shared interests as well as expanded implementation of shared political strategies, educational programs and business models.

Prior S2KM annual reports about the structured settlement industry and reports about industry association conferences are available on S2KM's structured settlement wiki.

NSSTA and NASP 2010 Educational Conferences - 2

The National Structured Settlement Trade Association ( NSSTA ) and the National Association of Settlement Purchasers ( NASP ) have announced agendas and speakers for their 2010 educational conferences scheduled concurrently and coincidentially next week (November 10-12, 2010) in Las Vegas.

S2KM has published an introductory report for these conferences plus historical reporting about past NSSTA and NASP educational conferences. S2KM's Managing Director, Patrick Hindert, will attend portions of the NSSTA conference (as a member) and participate at the NASP conference (as a moderator and speaker).

S2KM recommends both the NSSTA and NASP educational conferences to all structured settlement stakeholders and offers this preliminary comparative analysis.

Topics

NSSTA and NASP will both address several similar issues:

• Ethics - NSSTA and NASP could enhance their discussions by addressing "business practices" including the "Standards of Professional Conduct" adopted by the Society of Settlement Planners (SSP) on March 7, 2008.
• Legal update - NSSTA's legal committee represents a strategically important structured settlement industry knowledge resource. That said, NASP's structured settlement legal updates are equally diverse and valuable - especially when you include NASP's related "Industry Updates".
• Legislative update - Eric Vaughn is NSSTA's Executive Director, federal lobbyist and legislative guru. NSSTA lobbying weaknesses (especially state lobbying) play to NASP lobbying strengths and suggest collaborative opportunities.
• Marketing - Try a Google search for "structured settlement". Where are NSSTA, SSP and other primary market  participants?

With some important differences:

• NSSTA
  • Medicare/Medicaid - NASP is expected to address these issues as part of NASP's "Industry Analysis".
  • Certification - NASP does not have a certification program.
  • Life care planners - NSSTA, NASP (and SSP) educational programs historically have ignored this important settlement consulting professional community.
  • In force structured settlements - a strange attempt by NSSTA to educate its members about secondary market issues.
  • Wrongful imprisonment - a narrow focus compared with NASP's anticipated tax analysis.
  • Life expectancy - hopefully, NSSTA will link this discussion with related Medicare and Medicaid issues. Whatever happened to the structured settlement industry's life expectancy study initiated by Roger Harbin and Steve Smith?
• NASP
  • Industry analysis - NSSTA's educational programs typically provide limited strategic analysis with only one perspective and no outside critics. NASP features more open discussion of strategic industry issues featuring critics and alternative perspectives.
  • Taxation life cycle - Both NASP and SSP have previously featured Jeremy Babener as a speaker. Why not NSSTA? Babener's NASP presentation promises to be one of the highlights of these two structured settlement educational conferences.
  • Capital markets - NSSTA's educational programs historically lack analysis of the financial markets. NASP's annual panel sets the industry standard.
  • Dodd Frank legislation - a good example of NASP analysis of federal legislation that impacts both the primary and secondary structured settlement markets.

Speakers

NSSTA and NASP speakers both include a mix of association members and non-members. Both associations typically feature judges, attorneys and legislators as speakers. NSSTA's legislative speakers are generally federal while NASP's legislative speakers are generally state.

NSSTA speakers do not include SSP or NASP members. NASP speakers include both NSSTA and SSP members and thereby generate more comprehensive and valuable strategic discussions.

NASP 2010 featured speakers who are members of NSSTA and/or SSP:

• NSSTA
  • Peter Vodola
  • John Darer
  • Patrick Hindert
• SSP
  • Richard Risk

Previous NASP speakers who are members of NSSTA and/or SSP

• NSSTA
  • Stephen Harris
  • Michael Upchurch
  • Patrick Hindert
• SSP
  • Jack Meligan
  • Richard Risk

For more comprehensive S2KM reporting about  NSSTA, NASP and SSP, see S2KM's structured settlement wiki.

NAMSAP 2010 Annual Meeting

The National Alliance of Medicare-Set Aside Professionals (NAMSAP) hosted its Sixth Annual Meeting and Educational Conference in Arlington, Virginia on September 30-October 1, 2010. The meeting demonstrated NAMSAP's expanding leadership role within both the special needs settlement planning and structured settlement industries.

The NAMSAP meeting also highlighted:

• The increasing importance and complexity of the Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) statute for all personal injury stakeholders;
• The need for these personal injury stakeholders (and their professional associations) to cooperate politically and educationally;
• The challenges of integrating structured settlements with Medicare set-aside arrangements (MSAs) in the context of health care reform, CMS MSA regulations and related judicial rulings;
• The evolving business models, claim management strategies and professional skill sets which are now emerging to address these challenges.

According to its website, "NAMSAP is the only non-profit association exclusively addressing the issues and challenges of the Medicare Secondary Payer Statute and its impact on workers’ compensation and liability settlements". Founded in 2004, NAMSAP now has more than 500 members representing multiple professional disciplines. In additional to its annual conference, NAMSAP provides its members with other educational resources including a popular list serve and frequent webinars. NAMSAP's political priorities include its membership in the Medicare Advocacy Recovery Coalition (MARC).

The NAMSAP educational conference featured the following topics and speakers:

• Keynote speaker - Eric Vaughn, Executive Director of the National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA), proposed greater cooperation between NAMSAP and the structured settlement industry to "improve and grow" both the MSA and structured settlement markets. Vaughn urged NAMSAP members to become more active in federal lobbying and suggested strategies for achieving lobbying success.
• Professional administration panel - Rob Brown, Hany Abdelsayed, and Bob Barson set a new standard for successfully engaging audience participation as they discussed the challenges of post-settlement administrative compliance and why post-settlement compliance is important for all MSA stakeholders.
• Structured settlement panel - Patrick Hindert, Christine Phillips, Brian Fillion,and Jeffrey Swigart reviewed statutory history, CMS requirements and recommended documentation for structured settlements and MSAs. They discussed best practices, provided case examples and explained why structured settlements produce consistent cost savings in the MSA context.
• Legal update panel - Mark Popolizio, Jill Schroeder and Martin Cassavoy presented a summary analysis of several recent MSP cases including: Hadden v. United States; Haro v. Sibelius; United States v. Harris; and United States v. Stricker;
• MSA case study - Fran Provenzano developed and administered a competitive MSA case study exercise where teams of audience participants developed MSA allocations and projected future medical needs based upon medical records from an actual case. Team results were then compared with the allocations and projected costs CMS approved.
• Pharmacy panel - Dane Higgins, Matt Larkin, and Phil Walls discussed off-label use of medications and the impact of the May 14, 2010 CMS memorandum.
• Congressional panel - Congressional Assistant Laura Bozell and lobbyist Eric Rasmussen supplemented Eric Vaughn's keynote address with their own analysis of the upcoming 2010 federal elections and their recommendations for how best to lobby members of Congress and their staffs.
• Rated age discussion panel - Ismael Acevedo, Dan Durbin, John Meaney, and David Korch summarized annuity pricing and the role of rated ages in the settlement process. They highlighted problems for annuity providers and their structured settlement agents created by recent CMS rated age requirements and offered ideas for improving the rated age process for MSAs.
• MARC update - Roy Franco, co-chairman and founder of MARC, summarized MARC's 2010 accomplishments and legislative initiatives and highlighted continuing problems created by the MMSEA legislation.

Additional reasons for the success of the NAMSAP 2010 educational program were the diversity and intellectual strength of the audience and the quality and time allocated to the several exhibitors. In addition to the presenters, several leaders from both NSSTA and SSP attended the NAMSAP conference. Other attendees included defense attorneys, plaintiff attorneys, special needs attorneys, MSA attorneys, MSA administrators, MSA allocators, and rehabilitation specialists, as well as structured settlement underwriters, annuity providers and consultants.

NAMSAP announced their new officers and directors during the meeting:

• President - Michael Westcott
• Vice President - Jon Gice
• Treasurer - David Korch
• Secretary - Douglas Shaw
• Additional Directors - Barbara Bate; Ben Basista; Robert Brown; Raphael Gonzolez; Mark Popolizio; Fran Jacoby Provenzano; and Leslie Schumacher.

For S2KM reporting about prior NAMSAP conferences, see S2KM's structured settlement wiki.

For Patrick Hindert's NAMSAP structured settlement power point, see the TSSG website.

SSP and NSSTA 2010 Annual Meetings - 9

The Society of Settlement Planners (SSP) and the National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA) should be congratulated - especially immediate past-Presidents Joseph Tombs and Daniel Durbin - for excellent 2010 annual meetings.

S2KM's complete coverage of the SSP and NSSTA 2010 annual meetings is available on S2KM's structured settlement wiki.

Continuing post-meeting S2KM commentary:

• Both the SSP and NSSTA 2010 meetings occurred in Washington, D.C. at nearby hotels during the same week - May 2-7.
• Attendance at both the SSP and NSSTA meetings was good (not great) - despite the economic downturn in structured settlements.
• Approximately 10 persons attended portions of both the SSP and NSSTA meetings.
• The scheduling conflicts between SSP and NSSTA occurred primarily on the morning of May 4 - which created difficult choices for persons attending both conferences.
• Unless otherwise indicated, S2KM's comments are limited to educational programs Patrick Hindert, S2KM's Managing Director, personally attended.
• For pre-program educational listings (topics and speakers) for both the SSP and NSSTA meetings, see this prior S2KM blog post.
• S2KM opted to attend NSSTA meetings on May 4 and missed valuable SSP presentations including two Medicare set-aside arrangement (MSA) panels organized by Jason Lazarus, SSP's new President for 2010-2011.
• Both SSP and NSSTA prioritized MSAs in 2010 with four MSA educational programs - three by SSP.
• Douglas Brand, a featured SSP speaker about MSAs, has also served as the key NSSTA Director in developing NSSTA's government benefits committee and educational program.
• Joseph Tombs, SSP's 2009-2010 President, and Director of SSP's settlement planning certification program, continued SSP's educational series about "Minors Settlements" initiated by Texas attorney Phillip McCrury during the SSP 2009 annual meeting.
• As positive hallmarks of their SSP and NSSTA presidencies, both Tombs and Durbin successfully played to their personal and association strengths. For Tombs, learning, improvement, and industry growth. For Durbin, public policy, lobbying, protect and preserve during industry transition.
• As SSP President, Joseph Tombs continued and elevated SSP's excellent educational programs, including the Registered Settlement Planner Program,which Tombs developed and manages in partnership with SSP and Texas Tech University.
• Jason Lazarus, a respected knowledge leader within multiple settlement consulting communities, succeeds Tombs as SSP's President.
• SSP's educational and political strategies continue to espouse "improve and grow" - for both the structured settlement and settlement planning industries.
• Daniel Durbin led NSSTA's leadership transition from Joseph Ricci to Eric Vaughn and Peter Arnold. During this transition, NSSTA sharpened and expanded its political focus and delivered on its promise to "protect and preserve" IRC sections 130 and 104(a)(2).
• Michael Kelly succeeds Durbin as NSSTA's 2010-11 President and will be joined on the NSSTA Board of Directors by five newly (re) - elected Directors - Joseph Barnet; Len Blonder; Randy Dyer; James Ebel; and John Machir.
• Karen Meyers continues her industry role as director of NSSTA's Certified Structured Settlement Consultant (CSSC) program in partnership with the University of Notre Dame.
• Among retiring NSSTA Directors, S2KM's Managing Director Patrick Hindert, a NSSTA member, has interacted primarily with former NSSTA Directors Joseph Shannon and Douglas Brand.
• Both Shannon and Brand (and all retiring NSSTA Directors) deserve industry thanks:
  
  • Shannon served as liaison between NSSTA's Board of Directors and NSSTA's legal committee.
  • Brand served as liaison between NSSTA's Board of Directors and NSSTA's government benefit committee.
• The SSP and NSSTA 2010 annual meetings highlighted the need for new Internet-based structured settlement educational strategies and resources.
• The combined SSP and NSSTA structured settlement learning experience was overwhelming. Incredibly rich structured settlement knowledge was crammed into less than 5 days without any announced (to date) knowledge capture and/or post-conference knowledge distribution.
• Except for NSSTA references to the new NSSTA website, neither SSP nor NSSTA offered any Internet educational ideas or discussions at their 2010 annual meetings.

Post-conference leadership questions:

• How will SSP's and NSSTA's new leaders respond to industry changes, challenges and opportunities?
• Who are the young (under age 40) structured settlement industry leaders?
• When and how will SSP and NSSTA transition their educational strategies to embrace the Internet?
• What shared interests exist between SSP and NSSTA to improve and grow the structured settlement industry?

SSP and NSSTA 2010 Annual Meetings - 5

One of the highlights of the NSSTA 2010 Annual Meeting was witnessing NSSTA's lobbying strategy and the resulting association contacts between NSSTA members and members of Congress and their staffs.

NSSTA, and the structured settlement industry, have benefited historically from its two primary lobbyists - James Corman (now deceased) and Eric Vaughn (NSSTA's new Executive Director). Vaughn's lobbying expertise and leadership were featured during NSSTA's 2010 meeting in Washington.

NSSTA's political capital and relationships with Congress, especially the Senate Finance and House Ways and Means Committees, are strategically important for the structured settlement and settlement consulting industries. Last week in Washington, D.C.,Congressman after Senator after Congressman swore his allegiance to structured settlements during the NSSTA meeting in the political context of increasing federal financial deficits, the 2010 elections and anticipated 2011 tax reform.

Congressman David Camp, a Republican from Michigan and the ranking Republican on the House Ways and Means Committee, offered the most concise legislative endorsement of structured settlements. Camp stated: "With tax reform, everything is on the table. But structured settlements are not on the table. Congress has a long history of support for structured settlements on a bi-partisan basis. Don't expect much debate over structured settlements."

Congressman Sander Levin, a Democrat from Michigan who chairs the House Ways and Means Committee, also endorsed structured settlements stating: "there is no need for concern of someone trying to change the tax laws in the middle of the night to negatively impact structured settlements".

In addition to presentations by, and receptions with, numerous members of Congress, NSSTA's lobbying strategy featured coordinated Capital Hill meetings by NSSTA members with individual members of Congress and their staffs.

By comparison with NSSTA, SSP's lobbying is restricted and focused upon single claimant 468B qualified settlement funds. SSP does not retain a registered lobbyist on a continuing basis.

S2KM reporting about the SSP and NSSTA 2010 Annual Meetings:

• Part 1 - topics and speakers.
• Part 2 - S2KM's strategic perspective - before the meetings.
• Part 3 - NSSTA and SSP leadership changes.
• Part 4 - awards and recognition.
• Part 5 - NSSTA's lobbying strategy - this post.

SSP and NSSTA 2010 Annual Meetings - 3

Among several headlines resulting from the SSP and NSSTA 2010 Annual Meetings, "leadership changes" is most important.

The National Structured Settlement Trade Association (NSSTA) re-introduced its lobbyist, Eric Vaughn, as NSSTA's new Executive Director effective July 1, 2010. Vaughn follows Joseph Ricci of Smith Bucklin who succeeded Randy Dyer in 2008. NSSTA also named Peter Arnold, formerly NSSTA's marketing consultant, as Associate Executive Director. Hogan & Hartson (now Hogan Lovells) continues as NSSTA's legal counsel with Craig Ulman and John Stanton serving as primary legal advisers.

NSSTA elected five new members to its Board of Directors and introduced Michael Kelly as NSSTA's new President. The newly-elected NSSTA Directors are:

• Joseph Barnett
• Len Blonder
• Randy Dyer
• James Ebel
• John Machir

The Society of Settlement Planners (SSP) named Jason Lazarus as its President for 2010-2011 and Charles Schell as Vice President.

For additional S2KM reporting about SSP and NSSTA, see S2KM's structured settlement wiki and these earlier 2010 S2KM blog posts: 

• SSP and NSSTA 2010 Annual Meetings - 1 - for a complete list of speakers and topics;
• SSP and NSSTA 2010 Annual Meetings - 2 - for a preliminary S2KM strategic orientation.