Life Insurer Liquidation Process

What happens if and when a multistate life insurance company like Executive Life Insurance Company of New York (ELNY) is liquidated?

The answer: no one knows for certain. This uncertainty, specifically for ELNY, results from many factors:

• No significant multistate life insurers have failed since 1994.
• Many state life insurance guaranty association laws have been amended since 1994.
• Different state life insurance guaranty laws provide significantly different coverage applications, caps and requirements.
• ELNY's current negative surplus is historically large compared with previously liquidated life insurers.
• The vast majority of ELNY's remaining liabilities consist of structured settlement obligations.
• A 2007 "Agreement in Principle" to address ELNY's problems has never materialized.
• In a 2007 Business Insurance article, Mark Peters, then head of the New York Liquidation Bureau (NYLB) stated that this proposed bail-out plan “would be cheaper for the insurers and avoids the ‘chaos’ that would come with a liquidation.” (emphasis added)
• As ELNY's Rehabilitator, the New York Insurance Superintendent has repeatedly extended the original July 1, 2011 state court imposed deadline for filing a plan of liquidation, most recently to September 1, 2011.
• According to some critics, including New York attorney Peter Bickford, the problems with the insurer liquidation process in New York are systemic and lack transparency and accountability.
• New York has two state life and health insurance guaranty funds with different coverage dates, caps and requirements.
• The 2010 Dodd Frank law created a Federal Insurance Office (FIO) which could eventually supervise some life insurer insolvencies.

How U.S. life insurer liquidations are supposed to work

The United States federal bankruptcy law expressly excludes insurance companies from the definition of "debtor". As a result, when a life insurance company fails, it does not enter bankruptcy. Instead, the insurance commissioner (or superintendent) of the state that granted the life insurer's charter (domiciliary state) places the company in receivership - a status which can include conservatorship, rehabilitation and/or liquidation depending upon the severity of the insurer's problems. Liquidation is the most serious form of receivership.

All forms of life insurer receivership are conducted pursuant to the domiciliary state's insurance receivership statute under the supervision of a state court. Thirty-two states have adopted some version of the Insurers Rehabilitation and Liquidation Model Act which the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) adopted in 1978. This Model Act helps to achieve uniformity and encourages reciprocity among the states.

ELNY was placed into rehabilitation on April 23, 1991 by the New York Superintendent of Insurance, a status it retains to the present day under the supervision of the NYLB. Prior to 1991, ELNY sold an estimated 8,000 structured settlement annuities which, according to ELNY's most recent financial statements (December 31, 2010) continue to represent "the vast majority of the value of ELNY's remaining contract liabilities." To date, all related ELNY structured settlement payments have been paid in full. However, the most recent ELNY financial statements show assets of $905,945,200 compared with liabilities of $2,474,317,342 resulting in a negative surplus of $1,568,372,142.

If and when the insurance commissioner (or superintendent) determines that a life insurer should be placed in liquidation, the commissioner petitions a state court for an Order of Liquidation. On December 17, 2010, a New York State Supreme Court Judge ordered the Superintendent of the New York State Insurance Department to present the Court with a proposed Order and Plan of Liquidation for ELNY on or before July 1, 2011 - a date which has now been pushed back twice most recently to September 1, 2011.

In most states, following an order of liquidation, the court appoints the commissioner/superintendent as liquidator and grants the liquidator title to all of the life insurer's assets and, subject to court approval, control of the life insurer's operations with the objective of winding up the life insurer's business. In New York, the NYLB, acting as agent for the Superintendent of Insurance, generally serves as liquidator in life insurance insolvency proceedings.

The liquidator is responsible for "marshalling" the insurer's assets, evaluating the claims of policyholders and creditors, and distributing assets to approved claimants according to statutorily prescribed priorities. Alternatively, as was the case with Executive Life Insurance Company of California (ELIC), a liquidation plan may provide for the transfer of some or all of the failed insurers assets and/or liabilities to a new and/or healthy insurer. The objective, with either alternative is to protect policyholders and consumers against three risks:

• Delays in claim payments;
• Uncertainties about payment amounts; and
• Replacement costs for defaulted policies.

An Order of Liquidation also generally triggers involvement by one or more state life and health insurance Guaranty Associations. These state Guaranty Associations are specially chartered, not-for-profit legal entities created pursuant to state guaranty association legislation. All fifty states, plus Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia, have enacted some version of the NAIC's Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Association Model Act which was first promulgated in 1971. Important differences, however, exist among these various state statutes including coverage caps and whether the Guaranty Associations protect annuity policyholders or payees.

All state life and health guaranty associations are also members of the National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations (NOLHGA), a not-for-profit organization founded in 1983. The core mission of NOLHGA and its member Guaranty Associations, according to NOLGA President Peter Gallanis, is "to ensure that consumers receive at least a statutorily prescribed base level of financial protection when a life or health insurance company fails. That protection may be achieved either by transferring to a healthy insurer the failed company's business that is in force at the time of the company's failure or by supporting the 'runoff' of that in-force business."

A 2009 NOLHGA document assessing ELNY and titled "Information and Guidance on Estimating Potential Guaranty Association Assessments Relating to Executive Life Insurance Company of New York ('ELNY')" includes the following paragraph:

"No guaranty association has yet to enter into a legally binding commitment to participate in any plan or contribute any level of funding. As a result, at this time, we cannot confirm which particular state guaranty associations will participate in any plan. It is estimated, however, that if a plan similar to the one that is being considered is adopted, the majority of the guaranty associations’ costs (e.g., 66-75%), will likely be borne by New York's guaranty associations. Currently, it is estimated that 20-30 guaranty associations may eventually participate in a final plan once it is completed. In most states, assessments by guaranty associations relating to annuities are primarily associated with the allocated annuity account. New York has two separate guaranty associations: the assessment base for its “new” guaranty association is primarily associated with its life insurance, annuity and funding agreement account; while the assessment base for its “old” guaranty association is based upon admitted assets."

The 2009 NOLHGA document also includes a section titled "Guidance on Estimating a Company’s Potential Guaranty Association Assessment".

For S2KM's complete reporting and analysis of ELNY, including an Executive Life timeline, see the structured settlement wiki.

Comments

[home insurance orlando]

Liquidation is the most serious form of receivership.